One of the most popular communities provided by {{page_data.agentName}}

Casey Key

One of the most popular communities provided by Michael Graf

Casey Key

About Casey Key

<p>Casey Key is a hidden gem along Florida’s Gulf Coast, known for its quiet elegance and breathtaking beachfront estates. This narrow barrier island offers stunning views of the Gulf and Intracoastal Waterway, with many homes boasting private beach and dock access. Free of high-rises and commercial crowds, Casey Key is all about privacy, natural beauty, and a laid-back coastal lifestyle. Just minutes from Venice and Sarasota, it’s a serene escape for those seeking luxury, exclusivity, and true Old Florida charm.</p>

One of the most popular communities provided by Michael Graf

466

# of Listings

2

Avg # of Bedrooms

$408

Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.

$723,683

Med. List Price

Browse Casey Key Real Estate Listings

All listings

$250,000 - $500,000

466 Properties Found. Page 26 of 32.

Own your own rack at beautiful Gulf Harbor Marina, in Nokomis, on the intercoastal waterway between Pop's and Pelican Alley restaurants. It's just a short boat ride to the Venice jetty and out to the gulf for a day of fishing or cruise the intercoastal water way for lunch or dinner. This rack is the 3rd rack up, dimensions are 9'8" W X 25' D X 8' H. The maximum vessel dimensions for this rack are 8.8' W X 25' D X 6'6". The monthly maintenance fee is $404.

NOKOMIS

100 CIRCUIT ROAD N43

None Beds

None Baths

N/A

$20,000

MLS#: D6142034

Own your own boat rack in the highly sought-after Gulf Harbor Marina, perfectly located on the scenic Intracoastal Waterway in Nokomis. Enjoy quick and easy access to the Gulf of Mexico—just a short boat ride away—and cruise over to the popular boating hotspot, Snake Island, in just minutes. Also conveniently located between two waterfront restaurants, Pops and Pelican Alley, making grabbing dinner and lunch with friends a breeze. Fuel onsite and discounted for rack owners. On-site bait, food, and drinks. Monthly maintenance just $404. This top rack unit is 10’ wide x 35’ deep x 8’6” high. Maximum Boat Size: 9’ wide x 35’ long x 7’ high.

NOKOMIS

100 CIRCUIT s13

None Beds

None Baths

N/A

$20,000

MLS#: N6139124

Fabulous Gulf to Bay property on beautiful Casey Key, one of the most unusual keys on the West Coast of Florida. Immaculately kept three bedroom home with a dock on the bayside of Casey Key. Cabana across the street overlooks the Gulf of Mexico. Beautiful views from the living room across the pool to the bay. Updated kitchen with granite countertops and stainless appliances. Primary bedroom has a king, first guest bedroom has a king and second guest bedroom has twins. Primary bathroom has a tub and shower, 2nd bathroom has a shower only and the 3rd bathroom has a tub. CASEY KEY, GULF TO BAY, BEACH, VENICE, SARASOTA

NOKOMIS

3434 CASEY KEY ROAD

3 Beds

3 Baths

2,753 Sq.Ft.

$16,000

MLS#: A3993654

The west-facing property is tucked away on 135 feet of shoreline on the widest section of Blackburn Bay and showcases spectacular sunsets over Casey Key. The residence has a lovely screened pool and deck with a bay view framed by oaks, seagrapes and Florida friendly landscaping. Happy hour, anyone? It’s likely you’ll see manatees swimming around the dock and dolphins jumping in the bay, as well as, sea and shorebirds. There’s easy boat access to the Gulf of Mexico through the Venice Jetties under the Albee Bridge to the south and Big Pass in Sarasota Bay through the Blackburn Point swing bridge to the north. Dock at one of the many restaurants along the Intercoastal waterway. Take a short 5 mile trip by car to bustling and renewed downtown Venice to shop and dine, or travel 20 miles north to downtown Sarasota, the “cultural mecca of Florida.” Consider renting a golf cart for your stay! It’s only 3 miles on the back road to Nokomis Public Beach on pristine and exclusive Casey Key where shelling is bountiful and fun is guaranteed. 421 Waterside’s location is secluded and serene yet, quick access to grocery stores, pharmacies, retail, hospital and gas. Term of 6+ months will be considered.

NOKOMIS

421 WATERSIDE LANE

4 Beds

3 Baths

4,188 Sq.Ft.

$13,000

MLS#: A4574056

New photos coming soon. This turn-key vacation rental is island living at its best all year long. It's currently under renovation which include new bathroom and kitchen cabinets and counter tops. New appliances include induction/convention range. There is new flooring. 2709 sits directly on a wide stretch of beach and access to the shoreline is just steps away and is unencumbered by rip-rap. While the winter "season" offers refuge from the cold, summertime offers its own special experiences. Guests have witnessed loggerhead turtles nest in front of the house from May 1 to October 31. There's an unobstructed sweeping view of the Gulf that spans from the north Venice jetty to Siesta Key and showcases spectacular sunsets. Casey Key is a small, narrow barrier island that provides privacy, quiet, and an abundance of wildlife. Dolphins, manatees and tarpon migrate offshore. Osprey and pelicans put on a show soaring and diving for fish. Ibis, egrets and sandpipers are just a few of the species that scamper and feed in the shoreline. The tides will wash up mounds of seashells, as well as prehistoric shark teeth. Although there isn't a dock, there's room for a boat trailer with public launches to the north and south, both approximately 3 miles away. Monthly rentals have priority, but will consider weekly rentals. One week rate: $5,000; two-week rate: $8,250; three-week rate: $11,000. Rentals of less than six months are subject to 13% tax.

NOKOMIS

2709 CASEY KEY ROAD

3 Beds

3 Baths

4,657 Sq.Ft.

$13,000

MLS#: A4564225

CASEY KEY HOME... This home has room for everyone with five bedrooms and two full bathrooms and two half bathrooms. This is an interior lot with the utmost in privacy with a heated pool and hot tub. Only a few steps from a private access to the Casey Key Beach. The house also has access to a day dock on the intracoastal. This home offers two separate kitchen areas and living rooms. The first floor has two bedrooms and one and half bathrooms. On the second floor there are three bedrooms one and half bathrooms. There is also a bonus room on the second floor that could be a playroom or den. It is a short drive to the North Bridge on Blackburn Point Road, near restaurants and shopping. Come and discover a Florida paradise!!!

NOKOMIS

3708 SANDSPUR LANE

5 Beds

2 Baths

3,222 Sq.Ft.

$13,000

MLS#: A4521650

Now available for lease, experience refined coastal living in this stunning two-story custom home located in the exclusive gated community of Casey Key Estates. Offered fully furnished, this beautifully updated residence blends elegance with comfort, ideal for seasonal or long-term rental. Remodeled in 2022, the home features a designer kitchen with upscale finishes, a butler’s pantry, renovated baths, natural wood flooring, and a spacious laundry room. Modern conveniences include a new roof, whole-home generator, and high-end furnishings throughout. The first floor offers a light-filled great room with a fireplace, a formal dining area, private office/den, and a luxurious primary suite with views of the resort-style pool and spa. Upstairs, you'll find three guest bedrooms, a second living room, and a balcony overlooking the tranquil grounds of Casey Key. Outdoors, enjoy entertaining on the covered travertine patio, relax in the heated spa, or take advantage of the versatile game room, ideal for workouts, remote work or recreation. The oversized garage provides ample storage and parking. As a resident of Casey Key Estates, you'll enjoy private deeded beach access, pickleball and tennis courts, a community fishing pier, kayak launch and secure gated entry—all just minutes from Venice and Sarasota. Available for lease or sale—schedule your private showing today and step into a turnkey Florida lifestyle like no other.

NOKOMIS

1040 GULF WINDS WAY

4 Beds

3 Baths

7,615 Sq.Ft.

$12,000

MLS#: N6139777

Take a break and unwind at this peaceful oasis. Casey Key is a great option if you are looking for the quieter side of Gulf Coast living. Come see another reason everyone is asking What's all the fuss about Sarasota?" This get away sits on .75-acre lot, just steps from Nokomis Beach. This rental is also perfect for beach lovers and is well-suited for family gatherings. This spacious house offers 3 beds, 4 baths & approx. 3,873 sq .feet of living space. Separate Guest suite for another family, in-laws, or those beach-loving sunburned kids. This paradise features: Elevated terrace with Gulf of Mexico views, Private Deeded Beach access, Separate lower level living area w/ 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, office space, Living area, full kitchen, & laundry
Nearby fun includes- Casey Key Fish House and Tiki bar, Deep Lagoon Seafood or head to Sarasota/Siesta Key and see Crystal White Quartz Beaches, Sparkling Blue waters of Gulf of Mexico. Enjoy water activities like; Paddleboarding, Kayaking, Boating, Charter Cruises, JetSki's, Snorkeling, Fishing or for the more adventurous type-Parasailing! Or maybe just relax and play a couple rounds of Golf or Shop, Dine at many local eateries and local bars including, Ruth's Chris Steakhouse, Brine Seafood, TripleTail Seafood, Gecko's Grill and Pub, Local Favorite Walt's Fish Market for fresh local Stone Crab [Seasonal] or visit Cocktail World in Gulf Gate [4 bars in One- Zuzu, La De Dah (Jimmy Buffet bar) Deadwood Saloon (country bar) or Moondoggy's ( See Lynn:), Visit local attractions like Ringling Museum, Mote Marine Labs, multiple Seafood and music festivals downtown and on Siesta Key. Oh you asked about Alligators? visit Myakka State Park. Or visit old Florida and go to TRUE Island like Palm Island and visit Rum Bay bar and restaurant ( boat or Ferry required)or skip down to Boca Grande and catch a Tarpon or have a drink at the Pink Elephant just to name one local establishment. Or just stay local and Walk across the street to your private beach. Small and medium size dogs allowed. What else could one ask for? Available for Seasonal Rental starting Feb. 1 2025 $15,000/mo.+ applicable taxes Long Term Rental (6-12 month) at $9,500/mo.- $12,000/mo Seasonal rates. Option to Rent Main house> 2 x 2 (upstairs) or Lower unit (2 x 2) Admiral B's Fish Camp separately. $4,500 to $7,500 Off Season $7,000 to $12,000 Season. All Utilities included. Available 7/22/25 to 9/30/25.

NOKOMIS

3604 CASEY KEY ROAD

4 Beds

4 Baths

5,624 Sq.Ft.

$12,000

MLS#: A4628901

DIRECT GULF FRONT HOME IN A UNIQUE LOCATION. Gorgeous 1,750 SqFt of luxury on 3 stories, an Elevator, and the finishing are top quality. Sit on the balcony for a quiet evening and watch the most spectacular sunset on the West Coast of Florida. A 2 Bedrooms, 3 Bathrooms with plenty of living space for a Luxurious beach house. Could be leased-furnished or Turnkey furnished. Live on a very special Island, Casey Key an 8 miles Island with NO high rise and no traffic lights. Being close to Blackburn Bridge gives you easy access to many restaurants and shopping, Boat and Kayak rentals are just minutes away. It's a very special home, IT WILL MAKE YOU FEEL YOU ARE ON A LUXURY CRUISE watching the dolphins, and manatee playing in the water, watching the sea turtle coming ashore for nesting. Beach will gain and loose sand depending on storms. Paradise awaits. Don't miss this opportunity to live on Casey Key. Minimum 3 month rental $13,500 Monthly or annual $11,500 Monthly. Owner might consider 1 Month term.

NOKOMIS

3501 CASEY KEY ROAD

2 Beds

3 Baths

2,398 Sq.Ft.

$11,500

MLS#: A4568272

#A4660174

NOKOMIS

2414 BAYSHORE ROAD

3 Beds

3 Baths

5,700 Sq.Ft.

$10,000

MLS#: A4660174

#A4533330

NOKOMIS

3534 CASEY KEY ROAD

4 Beds

3 Baths

3,275 Sq.Ft.

$10,000

MLS#: A4533330

Available now! 6 months minimum *** Welcome to 507 Acacia Lane in Nokomis—a stunning, fully furnished new construction home available for rent just 0.3 mile from the beach. This elegant 5-bedroom, 4-bathroom residence is designed for comfort, style, and effortless coastal living. Inside, you'll find modern finishes, high-end furnishings, and a spacious layout that instantly feels like home. The heart of the property is the sparkling pool surrounded by a massive screened lanai, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor living space that extends the home and invites year-round enjoyment.

An outdoor kitchen enhances the space even more, while impact-rated windows and doors provide added security and peace of mind. The oversized 3-car garage allows plenty of room for vehicles, storage, and beach gear.

Located in one of Nokomis’ most desirable neighborhoods, the home is close to restaurants, shopping, and local attractions. Just a short walk away, Nokomis Beach is one of Sarasota County’s hidden gems—peaceful, unspoiled, and known for its soft sands, beautiful sunsets, and laid-back charm. Venice and Sarasota are also just minutes away, offering vibrant dining, entertainment, and cultural experiences.

The home is available for a minimum 6-month lease, with the possibility of an annual rental. Pool maintenance, lawn care, and internet are included in the rent, while the tenant pays for electricity and water. A security deposit is required.

Contact us today for more details or to schedule a private showing—this exceptional beachside retreat won’t last long.

NOKOMIS

507 ACACIA LANE

5 Beds

4 Baths

5,466 Sq.Ft.

$8,500

MLS#: A4657203

Casey Key is an amazing place to live, especially with views like this. This home is unfurnished and is now available as an annual rental. Sorry, no short term leases. New dock being installed with new 20,000lb lift, 16' between pilings and 14.6' beam. Minimum size boat it can handle is a 42'+ depending on type. This home is sitting on the Intracoastal waterway, aka Blackburn Bay with stunning views of the wide water way to your east & south while being in a protected cove with a minimal wake zone, watch dolphins and manatees playing as you relax by the pool or sit on the deck. This home is located just off the busier Casey Key Rd at the end of a cove, hence the name Casey Cove Rd. It is also at the end of the street just beside the point house at the end of a cul-de-sac. Other then your immediate neighbors there is no traffic and has the best possible views outside a point view. Very quiet and peaceful. Ride your bike or take a stroll in this small enclave and avoid the traffic worries as you ride. I just can't say enough how peaceful the neighborhood really is. The depth at low tide just off the seawall but before the center of the boat lift was 4'3" and High tide appears to run around 6' or so. Plenty deep for that sailboat or large power boat. You have 75' of seawall on the water way. There is a heated pool with spa in the rear of the home to relax in while enjoying these amazing water views with boats going by and birds flying above. Significant number of dolphins and manatees in this immediate area. The island across the way has all types of birds like Seagulls, Herons of all types, Osprey and brown Pelicans hanging out in the trees and occasionally the green Parrots who have adopted this area of FL for their home. All front windows are Hurricane windows as is the new beautiful front entry door. Schedule an appointment to view this excellent location in a laid back neighborhood on Beautiful Casey Key. Nokomis public beach is less then a mile away. House will be available for showings starting on June 15th 2025. Home is now unfurnished.

NOKOMIS

922 CASEY COVE DRIVE

2 Beds

2 Baths

2,026 Sq.Ft.

$8,000

MLS#: N6139147

This Home truly paints a picture of coastal paradise! From the private pathway leading to the pristine sands of Nokomis Beach providing access to endless adventures on the Gulf of Mexico, every detail seems designed to immerse residents in luxury and tranquility.

The three-level retreat embodies a masterpiece of design and comfort, with each floor offering its own unique charm. The screened-in balcony, where one can savor the coastal breeze while gazing at the mesmerizing waves, is the perfect spot for relaxation. And the fully enclosed yard, shaded by swaying palm trees, creates an idyllic setting for outdoor gatherings and leisurely moments.

Ascending to the third floor via elevator is like stepping into a world of unparalleled beauty, with the kitchen, living room, and primary bedroom strategically positioned to maximize the breathtaking views. The kitchen, adorned with stylish solid surface countertops and top-of-the-line appliances, is like a culinary haven where gourmet meals are effortlessly prepared. And the living room, with its panoramic vistas, promises moments of pure indulgence and relaxation.

After a full day of beachcombing or boating adventures, retreating to the luxurious embrace of the primary suite and all of its comforts. With a king bed, a walk-in closet and opulent bathroom featuring dual vanities and a large jetted soaking tub, it's a sanctuary of comfort and luxury. There is a second bedroom with a queen and a full bed and a third bedroom with 2 twin beds. In the family room, there are two queen size pull-out sofas.

Overall, this residence epitomizes coastal living at its finest. Impeccably maintained and freshly painted throughout, it's ready to welcome each guest to embrace the allure of Casey Key and make unforgettable memories in this breathtaking oasis of luxury.

Casey Key truly offers a beachside setting that's unmatched in its peaceful ambiance and natural beauty, making it an ideal destination for a vacation home retreat. With its pristine beaches and picturesque scenery, it's easy to see why travelers are drawn to this romantic city.

While staying in Casey Key, you'll have the opportunity to explore not only the local beaches but also the charming restaurants that add to the area's allure.

NOKOMIS

624 S CASEY KEY ROAD

3 Beds

2 Baths

5,202 Sq.Ft.

$8,000

MLS#: A4650772

Exclusive Casey Key Waterfront Rental | 3,000+ Sq Ft | Beach & Bay Access
Welcome to this rare rental opportunity on the prestigious barrier island of Casey Key. This spacious, over 3,000 sq ft, unfurnished home offers private beach and bay access, surrounded by lush tropical foliage and tranquil water views.
Inside, you'll find light-filled open living spaces with crisp white interiors, neutral tile and wood-style flooring, and walls of windows framing the natural beauty outside. The recently updated kitchen features clean white cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a breakfast bar overlooking the patio and greenery.
The primary suite captures stunning views of the Intracoastal Waterway and provides direct access to outdoor living areas. Multiple sliders lead to an expansive paver patio—ideal for entertaining, dining al fresco, or soaking in the peaceful setting.
This serene coastal home is perfect for those seeking the luxury of waterfront living with the flexibility to make it their own. Long-term lease only. Embrace the quiet elegance and coastal lifestyle of Casey Key.

NOKOMIS

2800 CASEY KEY ROAD

3 Beds

2 Baths

5,715 Sq.Ft.

$7,500

MLS#: A4658663

1 ... 24 25 26 27 28 ... 32

Buyers resources

7 Reasons to Work with a Realtor

7 Principles For Home Buying Success

Getting a Mortgage To Buy a Home

Home Hazards Awareness

Key Items For Home Inspection

Questions When Buying a Condo

Questions When Choosing a Realtor

Sellers resources

8 reasons to work with a realtor

Calculating Capital Gains

Checklist for Better Showing

Cleaning Home For Sale

Improving Odds Of an Offer

Preparing Home for photoshoot

Selling Your Home for More $$

Buyers resources

BUYERS RESOURCES

Sellers resources

SELLERS RESOURCES

properties found. properties found. Page of .

- property

Send a message

Message successfully sent.

First Name

Last Name

Email

Phone

MLS Property Number

Your message

Reason for contacting?

Buying a home

Selling a home

Other

I agree to receive email communication and understand I can unsubscribe at any time.

Virtual Assistant

Would you like to receive some additional information on this specific property or similar properties?

Yes, I would like more information.

Thank You for Your Reply, One of Our Agents will contact you as soon as possible

No, maybe later.

Thank you, you can always contact me via email, phone number or through the contact form.

Realhub AI

Lucy - Your AI-Powered Realtor

Update Your Temporary Password

Accessibility Menu

Personalize your search

Enter your email and we'll notify you immediately when new listings match what you're looking for.

or enter email address

Email address (Must be valid)

Already have an account ? Login here

Continue your home search

Email address

First name First Name

Last name Last Name

Phone number (Optional)

Password

I agree to receive communications and understand I can unsubscribe at any time.

Already have an account ? Login here