One of the most popular communities provided by {{page_data.agentName}}

Casey Key

One of the most popular communities provided by Michael Graf

Casey Key

About Casey Key

<p>Casey Key is a hidden gem along Florida’s Gulf Coast, known for its quiet elegance and breathtaking beachfront estates. This narrow barrier island offers stunning views of the Gulf and Intracoastal Waterway, with many homes boasting private beach and dock access. Free of high-rises and commercial crowds, Casey Key is all about privacy, natural beauty, and a laid-back coastal lifestyle. Just minutes from Venice and Sarasota, it’s a serene escape for those seeking luxury, exclusivity, and true Old Florida charm.</p>

One of the most popular communities provided by Michael Graf

475

# of Listings

2

Avg # of Bedrooms

$410

Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.

$722,328

Med. List Price

Browse Casey Key Real Estate Listings

$250,000 - $500,000

134 Properties Found. Page 3 of 9.

Some homes you walk through and forget. This one stays with you.

From the moment you step inside, there’s the unmistakable feeling of home. Light dancing across the wood look tile floors, the soft sophistication of crown molding and designer lighting, the way every room feels both beautiful and easy to live in.

Tucked at the edge of Toscana Isles on one of the deepest lots in the neighborhood, this is more than an address, it’s a place to breathe again…a sanctuary and landing place. No neighbors behind you, only open sky, a privacy fence, and plenty of room for your family to throw a frisbee or kick a ball.

Inside, you’ll find
• Over $60,000 in custom upgrades
• Professionally decorated interiors with a timeless, coastal-inspired style
• Plantation shutters throughout
• A kitchen with granite counters, a walk-in pantry, and space to gather
• A spacious primary suite with a generous walk-in closet and calming ensuite bath
• A versatile third bedroom, currently a sun-filled home office with French doors and full closet — perfect for guests, creative work, or retreat
This is a home where there is nothing to do but move in and begin living. It has sheltered us through storms, both in life and in weather, holding our family with safety, comfort, and joy.

And the lifestyle…
Morning coffee on the lanai while the breeze moves through the palms. Afternoons fishing or kayaking on the stocked community lakes. Evenings at the infinity-edge pool, a round of pickleball with friends, or a quiet golf cart ride through streets lined with neighbors who wave and stop to talk.

Toscana Isles is a gated, resort-style community offering tennis, bocce, a fitness center, dog park, playground, and a calendar of events that make it easy to connect.
Step inside and see if it feels like yours.

NOKOMIS

200 SOLIERA STREET

3 Beds

2 Baths

1,614 Sq.Ft.

$443,999

MLS#: TB8417871

#O6323689

NOKOMIS

485 SUN CHASER DRIVE

4 Beds

2 Baths

2,422 Sq.Ft.

$443,899

MLS#: O6323689

Welcome to Toscana Isles!
This beautifully maintained Clifton model offers 1,816 sq. ft. of thoughtfully designed living space in one of Nokomis’ premier gated communities. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, and a versatile flex space with a Murphy bed, this home provides both comfort and flexibility for guests or a home office.
The split-bedroom floor plan highlights a spacious great room that flows seamlessly to the covered, screened lanai—perfect for enjoying Florida’s outdoor lifestyle. Upgrades include crown molding, tile and luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, granite kitchen countertops, stainless-steel appliances and fresh interior paint throughout. The tile roof, brick paver driveway, and fenced backyard add to the home’s curb appeal and functionality. A 2-car garage provides plenty of storage. Step outside to a relaxing lanai surrounded by a spacious fenced yard perfect for pets to roam freely. Equipped with hurricane shutters for peace of mind.

Toscana Isles is a gated, maintenance-free, resort-style community featuring a Tuscan-inspired 8,000 sq. ft. clubhouse with an infinity-edge pool overlooking scenic lakes, state-of-the-art fitness center, billiards room with bar, catering kitchen, and event spaces. Outdoor amenities include tennis, pickleball, and bocce courts, a playground, dog park, fire pit, and over 200 acres of interconnected lakes for kayaking, canoeing, paddleboarding, and fishing. A full-time activities director keeps the social calendar vibrant. Located just minutes from Gulf beaches, Historic Downtown Venice, Wellen Park, shopping, dining, top-rated schools, and the Sarasota Memorial Hospital Venice Campus, with easy access to I-75.

NOKOMIS

151 VENTOSA PLACE

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,489 Sq.Ft.

$435,000

MLS#: A4662630

Attractive price with Calusa Lakes access. Golf, Tennis swimming pool (a semi private one in Falcon Trace) clubhouse with restaurant and Golf pro shop and much more. This is a an amazing value for this home set in a wooded and very private area of Falcon Trace on a dead end street. No through traffic here. High ceilings throughout with breakfast room off the kitchen and inside laundry. Tile floors with carpet in the bed rooms and a nice open plan welcomes you and friends home. This location is super prime at a great price. You are located just a few minutes Nokomis Beach and the North Jetty park, waterfront restaurants and the inviting downtown Venice shops and restaurants. Enjoy the culture and entertainment opportunities in Sarasota just a little north of this location. Need to travel interstate highway I-75 is close with easy north and south access. All of this adds up to quality enjoyment of central Sarasota county lifestyle. Calusa Lakes offers residents a clubhouse, with restaurant and bar the gold course has an aqua range for practice, putting green and Pro Shop, rental clubs and carts both electric and pull trollies. If you enjoy a private setting at home you'll love the back yard at this inviting home. Don't let the wonderful value get away it won't last at this price!

NOKOMIS

2292 HARRIER WAY

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,289 Sq.Ft.

$434,900

MLS#: N6137923

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Price Reduction! And closing cost credit to the buyer! Featuring a split floor plan with four bedrooms and two bathrooms, this well-positioned home is situated in the highly sought-after Toscana Isles community in Nokomis/North Venice. Conveniently located near Venice Island, Sarasota, and numerous beaches, this fabulous home has everything you're looking for. A spacious foyer welcomes you into this stylish home with an abundance of natural light, wood-look plank porcelain tile flooring, crown molding, plantation shutters, and beautiful light fixtures. The well-designed kitchen is spacious, modern, and bright, featuring white wood cabinetry, quartz countertops, a tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, a large kitchen island with seating for four, and a closet pantry. The spacious living room is comfortable and bright, designed for entertaining family and friends, and offers plenty of seating. Double sliding glass doors lead you to the oversized lanai, where you will enjoy peaceful evenings and hear the sounds of nature. The backyard is exceptionally large, with ample room to add your own pool, if desired. New backyard landscaping has just been added, making the outdoor space very private. The dining area creates a cozy atmosphere that is perfect for those special occasions, and is conveniently located near the kitchen and lanai. The two guest bedrooms, situated opposite the owner's suite, offer privacy for your overnight visitors and are adjacent to the second bathroom. The fourth bedroom is more private and is ideal for an office or a den. The Owner's retreat features an en-suite bathroom with a walk-in shower, a niche, and a shower seat, dual vanities, and his-and-hers closets. The laundry room includes a washer and dryer, room for storage, and is separate from the main living area. This fantastic amenity-filled community offers its residents an 8,000 sq ft clubhouse, a resort-style infinity pool and spa, a fire pit, a lakeside activities room, a fitness center with additional classes, pickleball and tennis courts, bocce ball, a playground, a dog park, and 200 acres of ponds for fishing and kayaking. Only a short drive to the natural allurements of Venice Beach, the Legacy Trail, the shopping/dining options of Downtown Venice, Sarasota, and Wellen Park. Hospitals, churches, and parks are all nearby. This home is NOT in a flood Zone and has had no hurricane damage. Combined with low HOA fees and proximity to all that Venice has to offer, this lovely home won't last long! Schedule your showing today!

NOKOMIS

260 SOLIERA STREET

4 Beds

2 Baths

2,700 Sq.Ft.

$432,000

MLS#: N6139255

Wonderful opportunity to own a nearly new and well-maintained home in the beautiful resort style community of Toscana Isles, just 4 1/2 miles from Nokomis Beach. This 3 bedroom, 2 bath, single family home is one of the more popular floor plans for its functionality and aesthetics. Lush landscaping, a paver driveway and walkway make your approach inviting. Arches grace the covered entry patio with a lighted front door to illuminate the interior entry, and a hideaway screen door for those cooler days. A bright and functional kitchen with solid wood white cabinetry, quartz counter tops with dazzling herringbone tile backsplash and a large island overlooking the great room. Luxurious trim carpentry finishes from elegant base board and casings to crown molding accent the home including 8-foot raised 6 panel doors. This home boasts contiguous wood plank style ceramic flooring throughout the entire home. The generous main bedroom has a dual lavatory ensuite with walk-in frameless glass shower and a large closet with built in cabinetry offering an abundance of shelving, hanging and storage space. The Garage has a wall of cabinets and heavy-duty shelving you will discover we all need. The community of Toscana Isles is renowned for it's luxurious infrastructure from bridges and fountains, expansive lakes and an amenity center with an abundance of features. Activities include tennis, pickleball, bocce ball, playground and a dog park, bring your kayak or canoe and plow the lakes or fish from the community dock. There is a fitness center, infinity edge pool, billiards room and BYOB bar along with activity rooms and on-site management to assist with event planning. Nestled between Sarasota and Venice offering the best of both, with shopping, dining and entertainment all close by. The Sarasota Memorial Hospital's new campus is a few minutes away. The proximity to both the Legacy Trail and the Myakka river makes this the perfect location for a dynamic lifestyle. Schedule your showing soon!

NOKOMIS

236 SOLIERA STREET

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,217 Sq.Ft.

$431,000

MLS#: N6138710

Move in Ready -spacious 1683 sq. ft. of living space the Tidewinds2 is on of Neal Communities' larger villa home design with 2 bedrooms, Den, 2 baths and a 2 car garage. A large island and plenty of counter space can be found in the well-appointed kitchen, overlooking the spacious great room and dining area, ideal for enjoying drinks with friends and family during the evening. Any time of the day, you can retreat tot he primary bedroom featuring an oversized walk-in closet, dual sinks and separate water closet. An extended outdoor lanai completes this floor plan. This beautiful homes also includes Impact Resistant Glass.

NOKOMIS

117 CORSERRA DRIVE

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,597 Sq.Ft.

$430,990

MLS#: TB8419071

David Weekley Homes at Vistera of Venice is a resort-inspired and maintenance included community that offers a variety of
amenities to its residents. The Club is the heart of this new community, where you can relax, mingle, and enjoy life more. Take a refreshing dip
at the resort-inspired pool, and later, bask in the Florida sunshine on the deck. Stay connected wherever you are with the community’s Wi-Fi.Vistera’s bike share program makes it easy to explore the world on two wheels. You can pick up your bicycle at the designated station and enjoy
the multi-use trails or venture out further. Transport yourself with natural beauty and clear your mind at Vistera’s serene recreational trail. The modern fitness center is fully equipped with
cardio and strength training equipment.
Welcome to The Queensgate, a beautifully designed 1,837-square-foot gem that combines modern luxury with functional elegance. This spacious floorplan features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, offering ample space for comfortable living.
The open-concept design seamlessly connects the living, dining, and kitchen areas, making it ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. You'll appreciate the study, perfect for a home office or a quiet retreat.
Step inside to discover a host of premium upgrades, including stunning wood laminate floors that enhance the home’s aesthetic appeal. The designer cabinets and quartz countertops throughout the home add a touch of sophistication and durability. Oversized windows flood the space with natural light, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere, while impact glass windows provide added security and energy efficiency.
Experience the perfect blend of style and practicality in The Queensgate—where every detail is crafted for modern living.

NOKOMIS

652 ALLORA AVENUE

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,460 Sq.Ft.

$429,990

MLS#: T3545707

Walk to the beach! Your wonderful place in the sun. This is for beach and boat lovers. Fabulous updated 2BR/2BA turnkey furnished unit is ready to go. New appliances, flooring, hardware & updated baths in 2021, spacious kitchen is marvelous with wood cabinets and granite. Tile & laminate flooring throughout. 3 year old metal roof (covered through association fees). Freshly painted exterior and interior. Nice back air conditioned, Florida room plus storage overlooks the huge deck in back with Hurricane sliders. New tankless water heater too. Small, friendly complex consists of 5 units and is right next to 2 restaurants, marina, Nokomis Beach & shops. This is a pet friendly 55+ community. You may rent it for a 30 day minimum 12 times a year. This is truly what you have been looking for.

NOKOMIS

100 BAYSHORE ROAD C

2 Beds

2 Baths

1,050 Sq.Ft.

$429,900

MLS#: A4660511

LOCATION-LOCATION-LOCATION ... Lovely 3-bedroom 2-bath home backs up to a tranquil Wooded Preserve with no fences or roads offering a premium quiet setting. All within a Gated Resort Style Community surrounded by Lakes and wildlife. Wood-look ceramic tile in the main traffic areas and plush carpet in the bedrooms. Open floorplan with abundant storage and closet space. Amazing Amenities include an absolutely breathtaking Clubhouse with kitchen for catered events, Lounge area with pool table, TV's, fitness room, playground, dog park, tennis and pickleball courts. The fantastic infinity community pool looks out over the lake with plenty of outdoor seating to soak up the sun and enjoy the view. Come see what the true the Florida Lifestyle is all about.

NOKOMIS

153 SOLIERA STREET

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,217 Sq.Ft.

$429,000

MLS#: A4631639

PRICE adjustment to get this salt water canal front home SOLD. If you are looking for a waterfront home with direct Gulf access , This is the home for you. NEW Roof finished 7/18/2025, New A.C. 2025, New kitchen cabinets 2025.
This home is situated on a beautiful saltwater canal, offering direct access to Dona Bay, just minutes from the Intracoastal Waterway (ICW) and the Gulf , just waiting for your coastal upgrades . With the Legacy Trail right around the corner, you'll enjoy easy access to biking and outdoor adventures. Local restaurants, cultural spots, parks, and more are all nearby. Downtown Venice is just across the bridge, and the beach is only 10 minutes away!
Bring Your Boat, Kayak, Paddleboard, and Bikes! Outdoor Living at Its Best

This property has tons of protentional and is ready for you to make it your own paradise . The neighborhood is peaceful and located on a quiet, dead-end street—perfect for privacy.

While the home does need some TLC, it has been priced with that in mind, giving you the opportunity to bring your vision to life. Recent updates include new kitchen cabinets, a new A/C unit, and a new hot water heater. New roof 07/15?2025. The home did experience water damage from Hurricane Milton and Helene, but the drywall has been replaced and freshly painted. Just add your own coastal vibe.

Don't miss the chance to create your dream waterfront retreat in this fantastic location!

NOKOMIS

504 BUENA VISTA DRIVE

2 Beds

2 Baths

2,196 Sq.Ft.

$429,000

MLS#: N6138022

SELLER FINANCING AVAILABLE!!!! ZERO DAMAGE FROM EITHER HURRICANE!!! EXTREMELY MOTIVATED SELLER, BRING ALL OFFERS!!! Beautiful 2023 build in the highly desirable Toscana Isles The Brighton! This gorgeous 1543 sq ft Great room plan has tons of upgrades vs the other properties in this community!!! Built with a tile roof and features brick paver driveway and covered screened lanai. Crown molding, tile and carpet throughout, stainless steel appliances, light bright cabinets, quartz kitchen countertops and wood look tile are just some of the many awesome features in this home!!! The generous sized master features a HUGE walk in closet and the home also features a large attached 2 car garage with a $2,500 custom paint job!!! Toscana is a lawn maintenance included gated community. Amenities include a community infinity pool, club room and fitness center all in a 8,000 sq ft Clubhouse. A community designed for active lifestyle including fishing, kayaking and canoes on a beautiful 60 acre lake. All centrally located close to Venice Island and it's fabulous beaches, restaurants and shoppin

NOKOMIS

120 MOSCATA WAY

3 Beds

2 Baths

1,544 Sq.Ft.

$425,000

MLS#: TB8363561

Welcome to your Florida retreat in beautiful Sorrento East!
This 3-bedroom, 2-bath split floorplan home offers the perfect blend of comfort and privacy. Enjoy spacious living with a formal living and dining room, plus a separate family room that opens to a covered patio and screened pool—ideal for entertaining or relaxing year-round.

Tile flooring runs throughout the home for easy maintenance. The primary suite includes a large walk-in closet and a private ensuite bath. Guest bedrooms are thoughtfully placed on the opposite side of the home for added privacy.

Start your mornings with coffee on the covered patio overlooking your sparkling open-air pool. The property is a 1/3 of an acre. And you're just 11 minutes from Nokomis Beach, and close to shopping, dining, and more.

Major updates include:

Tile Roof (2011)

Hot Water Heater (2016)

A/C System (2022)

Plumbing (Hot & Cold replaced in 2006)

Don't miss your chance to own this inviting Sorrento East home—schedule your showing today!

NOKOMIS

464 RUBENS DRIVE E

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,782 Sq.Ft.

$425,000

MLS#: A4658813

MAKE AN OFFER TODAY - Sellers are motivated and Ready for all Reasonable Offers! LIVING THE DREAM IN FLORIDA! This nearly new 2021-built villa with 2 BEDROOMS, 2 BATHROOMS, DEN & 2 CAR GARAGE is ideally situated in Vicenza, a gated Italian-inspired resort community designed for those who appreciate both beauty and tranquility. MOVE-IN READY & AVAILABLE NOW, there’s no need to wait for new construction. Nestled on a quiet, low-traffic street, THIS VILLA IS JUST A SHORT DISTANCE TO VICENZA’S AMENITY CENTER, INCLUDING TWO DOG PARKS, A RESORT-STYLE HEATED POOL WITH SPA & CABANAS, PICKLEBALL & BOCCE COURTS, A CLUBHOUSE, AND MILES OF TRAILS that wind through lush nature preserves. UNDERGROUND UTILITIES MEAN NO OVERHEAD POWER LINES NEAR THIS VILLA. From the moment you arrive, the expansive lawn and charming covered porch invite you to unwind and take in a breathtaking Florida sunset. Infused with a modern coastal aesthetic, this home HAS BEEN RECENTLY PAINTED and features a soothing palette of warm grays & crisp whites, complemented by designer lighting fixtures & contemporary ceiling fans. High ceilings add volume and openness, creating an airy ambiance throughout the home. Inside, large-format tile flooring flows seamlessly through the main living spaces, offering sophistication and ease of maintenance. At the front of the home, a light-filled versatile den or office space is enclosed by elegant double doors, providing both privacy and a peaceful retreat. The heart of the home is an open-concept great room, thoughtfully integrating the kitchen, dining and living areas into one cohesive space perfect for entertaining or casual everyday living. The gourmet kitchen features light gray cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless appliances including a gas range, and a timeless subway tile backsplash set in a herringbone pattern – blending style and functionality. Large sliding glass doors flood the space with natural light and opens to the screened lanai, where you’ll enjoy serene views of the nature preserve just beyond – your private piece of paradise. THE LANAI HAS OPTIMAL NORTHEAST ORIENTATION TO MINIMIZE AFTERNOON HEAT IN THE LIVING AREAS. THE FRONT PORCH FACES SOUTHWEST WHERE ONE CAN ENJOY A BEAUTIFUL SUNSET. The spacious primary suite, tucked away at the rear of the home for privacy, is a tranquil retreat. The en-suite bathroom is spa-inspired, complete with a luxurious walk-in shower, and separate vanities. The split floor plan offers privacy for guests, with a guest bedroom and full bathroom located at the front of the home. Vicenza is a vibrant, active-lifestyle community with regular social events. Residents enjoy LOW HOA FEES and NO CDD FEES. You’re going to love Vicenza’s convenient location to the Gulf Coast beaches, Venice Myakka River Park, Historic Downtown Venice, Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Atlanta Braves CoolToday Stadium, I75, golfing, boating, fishing, waterfront dining, fine dining, shopping, nightlife & more! This villa offers more than just a home, it’s a lifestyle waiting to be embraced! Don’t wait – schedule a showing today & be sure to ask about the home warranty sellers are including!

NOKOMIS

220 SAREZZO CIRCLE

2 Beds

2 Baths

2,201 Sq.Ft.

$425,000

MLS#: N6138591

A RARE FIND! TWO adjoining parcels are now available WEST OF TRAIL in the heart of Nokomis, FL! Each 1/4-acre lot may be purchased individually OR purchase BOTH lots for a spacious acre homesite, totaling slightly over 1/2 an acre — an incredible opportunity in a fully built-out neighborhood where a parcel of this size is nearly impossible to find. Prime Location just minutes to Nokomis Beach, Pop’s Sunset Grill, Venice Jetty, waterfront dining, shopping, and more. Enjoy the coastal lifestyle with boating, fishing, and Gulf sunsets right at your fingertips. Located just down the block from multimillion dollar bayfront homes, yet these parcels are NOT in a flood zone (flood zone X). No deed restrictions and no HOA mean you can enjoy your property, your way. Each SINGLE LOT (1/4 acre) is listed at $212,500.... or purchase BOTH LOTS (totaling over 1/2 an acre), listed at $425,000. The choice is yours! Whether you’re looking to build your Florida retreat or invest in land, this property offers unmatched potential. Don’t miss your chance to secure a piece of paradise in one of Nokomis’ most desirable locations!

NOKOMIS

LOTS 41-42 INDIANA AVENUE

None Beds

None Baths

0.51 acres

$425,000

MLS#: N6140119

1 2 3 4 5 ... 9

Buyers resources

7 Reasons to Work with a Realtor

7 Principles For Home Buying Success

Getting a Mortgage To Buy a Home

Home Hazards Awareness

Key Items For Home Inspection

Questions When Buying a Condo

Questions When Choosing a Realtor

Sellers resources

8 reasons to work with a realtor

Calculating Capital Gains

Checklist for Better Showing

Cleaning Home For Sale

Improving Odds Of an Offer

Preparing Home for photoshoot

Selling Your Home for More $$

Buyers resources

BUYERS RESOURCES

Sellers resources

SELLERS RESOURCES

properties found. properties found. Page of .

- property

Send a message

Message successfully sent.

First Name

Last Name

Email

Phone

MLS Property Number

Your message

Reason for contacting?

Buying a home

Selling a home

Other

I agree to receive email communication and understand I can unsubscribe at any time.

Virtual Assistant

Would you like to receive some additional information on this specific property or similar properties?

Yes, I would like more information.

Thank You for Your Reply, One of Our Agents will contact you as soon as possible

No, maybe later.

Thank you, you can always contact me via email, phone number or through the contact form.

Realhub AI

Lucy - Your AI-Powered Realtor

Update Your Temporary Password

Accessibility Menu

Personalize your search

Enter your email and we'll notify you immediately when new listings match what you're looking for.

or enter email address

Email address (Must be valid)

Already have an account ? Login here

Continue your home search

Email address

First name First Name

Last name Last Name

Phone number (Optional)

Password

I agree to receive communications and understand I can unsubscribe at any time.

Already have an account ? Login here