One of the most popular communities provided by {{page_data.agentName}}

Casey Key

One of the most popular communities provided by Michael Graf

Casey Key

About Casey Key

<p>Casey Key is a hidden gem along Florida’s Gulf Coast, known for its quiet elegance and breathtaking beachfront estates. This narrow barrier island offers stunning views of the Gulf and Intracoastal Waterway, with many homes boasting private beach and dock access. Free of high-rises and commercial crowds, Casey Key is all about privacy, natural beauty, and a laid-back coastal lifestyle. Just minutes from Venice and Sarasota, it’s a serene escape for those seeking luxury, exclusivity, and true Old Florida charm.</p>

One of the most popular communities provided by Michael Graf

533

# of Listings

2

Avg # of Bedrooms

$424

Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.

$762,878

Med. List Price

Browse Casey Key Real Estate Listings

All listings

$250,000 - $500,000

533 Properties Found. Page 6 of 36.

#A4639387

NOKOMIS

907 GARLAND AVENUE

4 Beds

2 Baths

3,313 Sq.Ft.

$949,000

MLS#: A4639387

Experience unparalleled luxury in this stunning custom-built Neal Signature pool home, featuring 3 spacious bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms—each bedroom with its own en suite—and a private in-law suite with separate entry. This thoughtfully designed residence showcases soaring 12-foot ceilings in the main living area with an elegant tray ceiling, a beautifully crafted built-in bookcase in the living room, 10-foot ceilings throughout the rest of the home, a gourmet kitchen with built-in ovens, crown molding, and upgraded solid core doors. The owner’s suite offers a serene retreat with dual walk-in closets and a spa-like bathroom featuring a huge walk-in shower. A dedicated office provides a perfect workspace, while the expansive lanai is an entertainer’s dream with an outdoor kitchen, panoramic screen enclosure, and tranquil lake views surrounding the pool and spa. Designed for durability and efficiency, the home includes hurricane impact windows for peace of mind. Located in Aria, a gated Neal Signature luxury community, residents enjoy access to a clubhouse, resort-style pool, pickleball courts, and a state-of-the-art fitness center. This immaculate home combines elegance, comfort, and versatility—don’t miss the opportunity to make it yours.

NOKOMIS

257 CORELLI DRIVE

3 Beds

3 Baths

3,576 Sq.Ft.

$945,000

MLS#: D6142122

LUXURY. LOCATION. LIFESTYLE. This stunning, fully renovated 5-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home offers over 3,000 sq ft of stylish living space, thoughtfully designed for both everyday comfort and high-end entertainment. Set on a private, wooded ¾-acre lot, this peaceful retreat has NO HOA, HIGH AND DRY-NO STORM DAMAGE, and public water already installed—all in a highly desirable location just minutes from the Gulf, Nokomis Beach, marinas, and shopping.
Every inch of this home has been meticulously upgraded with New Metal Roof, HVAC systems, electrical, plumbing, irrigation. All luxury upgrades inside home is Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring, Kitchen, Bathrooms, Closets, and Paint, ensuring a true move-in-ready experience with peace of mind. The open-concept floor plan invites you in with a spacious living room, architectural wood-accented dining area, and an Elegant and spacious Great Room featuring a built-in electric fireplace—all highlighted by luxury vinyl plank flooring, stylish lighting, and designer finishes throughout. French doors off the dining room lead to a charming brick patio with plenty of space to create your dream pool or outdoor entertaining space.
The heart of the home is a chef’s dream kitchen—complete with premium cabinetry, quartz countertops, built-in microwave/oven, stainless steel appliances, and a large waterfall-edge island perfect for gathering and entertaining.
The main-level Primary Suite is a versatile retreat with a walk-in closet behind barn doors, private wet bar, and luxe bathroom which you can either repurpose for your needs or making it ideal for a future pool bath if desired. Ensuite is conveniently connected to a spacious laundry room and the Great Room.
Upstairs, you’ll find a full In-Law Suite, complete with an oversized bedroom, office nook, large walk-in shower, walk-in closet, and private second-story deck—perfect for enjoying quiet morning coffee or sunset views.
Host with ease and welcome family and friends with 3 spacious guest bedrooms and a private In-Law Ensuite, all located on the second level—keeping the main-level Primary Suite your own personal retreat. This home is perfectly designed for entertaining and comfortable for all your guests.
Just minutes to shopping, beaches and marinas, this exceptional home offers the perfect blend of luxury living and Gulf Coast lifestyle.

NOKOMIS

425 LAUREL ROAD W

5 Beds

3 Baths

4,020 Sq.Ft.

$899,000

MLS#: D6141735

Recent market adjustment. Welcome to this 4 bedroom/ 3 bathroom updated custom home in the much sought after Calusa Lakes community. Beautiful brick pavers set the tone as you pull up to the exterior of the home. Entering the front door you will see the hickory wood flooring that continues throughout the house, 12 foot ceilings that are framed by painted crown molding. Both the spacious Living & Dining Rooms have been recently painted with custom drapes. The sliding glass doors open up and disappear showcasing the large swimming pool and golf course views. The updated kitchen boasts numerous cream glazed wood cabinets, new quartz counters with spaces for 3 counter height bar stools, newer GE Cafe stainless appliances, a side sink/coffee bar. The Family Room is spacious and highlighted by many windows that flood the room with natural lighting. A side door leads out to a small patio that is used for grilling. The bright & airy Primary Bedroom has a tray ceiling as well as sliding glass doors out to the lanai. Two closets complete this relaxing retreat. The spa like updated bathroom has lovely natural wood cabinetry with quartz counter tops. The shower is oversized and is next to a free standing tub & chandelier! The second bedroom in this wing is currently being used as an office and is conveniently across the hall from the pool bathroom. Bedrooms #2 & #3 are in the guest wing off the kitchen and have a door for privacy from the rest of the home. This wing has a full bathroom with a double vanity and walk-in shower. The lanai has brick pavers surrounding the resurfaced heated swimming pool. The southern exposure guarantees afternoon sun for sunbathing, cookouts, and watching the sunset. Great partial lake views along with the 10th green and 11th tee. Membership to the Golf Course is optional. The tennis/pickleball courts are open to all residents as well as the restaurant located in the Golf Pro Shop. This community is close to the Legacy Trail, shopping, Venice Island, I #75, airports, both Nokomis Beach & Venice beach, public boat ramps and marinas. Run don't walk to see this move-in ready home perfect for full time or seasonal owners. Paradise awaits!

NOKOMIS

2020 CALUSA LAKES BOULEVARD

4 Beds

3 Baths

3,888 Sq.Ft.

$895,000

MLS#: A4645937

Welcome to Talon Preserve on Palmer Ranch. This rarely available Mystique model home is the perfect entertaining home with endless upgrades throughout! This 3 bedroom, 2 bath plus den home sits on a premier water lot with an unobstructed view in both the back and front of home and is just steps away from the amenity center. Upgrades include a whole house generator, plantation shutters, water softener/ filtration system, 4ft. garage extension, new marble flooring in the primary bedroom and tile in the guest bedroom. A 20x30 custom commercial grade outdoor living area with retractable roof was added including an outdoor kitchen and hot tub making this space perfect for entertaining. The fenced in yard area allows the perfect space for your pets to enjoy. Talon Preserve on Palmer Ranch is a gated maintenance free community with premier resort-style amenities including a restaurant/ bar, community pool and hot tub, wellness and spa services, fire pit, sports courts, arcade, nature walking trails and direct access to legacy trail from the community.

NOKOMIS

14480 EAGLE BRANCH DRIVE

3 Beds

2 Baths

3,551 Sq.Ft.

$879,900

MLS#: A4624385

Experience luxury living in this beautiful custom home, positioned with serene views down the 11th fairway and a peaceful lake. Boasting spacious bedrooms, a private study, versatile bonus room and a split floor plan ensuring privacy, this residence offers comfort and flexibility. Notable features include volume and tray ceilings, crown molding, and a new roof in 2024. The well-designed kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring maple cabinetry, granite countertops, walk-in pantry, built-in desk and breakfast bar. It opens seamlessly to the breakfast nook with its aquarium windows and a welcoming family room, highlighted by sliding glass doors that lead out to the lanai. For formal occasions, enjoy the elegant dining room and living room with slider access to the lanai. Entertain effortlessly outdoors with a sparkling pool and spa, complemented by a fully equipped outdoor kitchen. The primary suite is set apart behind French doors and offers direct access to the lanai. Its luxurious bath includes a Roman shower, dual vanities, a garden tub and French doors opening to an attached bonus room. The driveway and lanai deck are beautifully finished with pavers for added curb appeal. In the gated community of Calusa Lakes, this home offers access to tennis courts, social activities, and is just minutes from the beach. Golf membership is optional, adding flexibility to your lifestyle.

NOKOMIS

2022 CALUSA LAKES BLVD

3 Beds

3 Baths

3,940 Sq.Ft.

$875,000

MLS#: N6138617

Under Construction. Welcome home to the Juniper built by M/I Homes! This exquisite 2 story home features 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, a Den, a Loft, 3 car garage, impact storm windows throughout, and a large lanai for relaxing in this beautiful Florida weather! In addition, the kitchen features nice upgrades as in quartz counter tops, gourmet kitchen, and a large island. On the Lower level, you have a Den, a half bath, dining room, great room, an eat in kitchen area and the owners suite with a super large walk in closet fit for a King and Queen! On the second floor, the loft area over looks down to the first floor foyer for an elegant feel. In addition to the loft, there are 3 additional bedrooms along with 2 full baths for your growing family or guests alike! Come make this home yours today!

NOKOMIS

1668 LUGANO CIRCLE

4 Beds

3 Baths

4,850 Sq.Ft.

$870,990

MLS#: R4908847

Price Includes: NEW 5/2025 ROOF. NEW 5/2025 POOL CAGE. NEWLY RESURFACED POOL 9/2024. NEW ELECTRICAL PANEL WITH BUILT IN SURGE PROTECTION 9/2024. Canal Home with NO 2024 water intrusion. This canal home with private pool is located in the highly desirable waterfront community of The Inlets. West of the Trail and just a mile from Nokomis Beach, you are in the perfect location to enjoy all Sarasota County has to offer. Lounge by your screened pool or use your backyard dock with lift to hop on your boat or kayak for easy access to the intracoastal waterway and the Gulf of Mexico beyond. This open and light-filled home is perfect for entertaining with sliding glass doors from the living room and kitchen that open to a large, covered porch and expanded screened pool area. The open kitchen is great for entertaining with a breakfast bar, granite countertops, and stainless-steel appliances. There are tile floors in all the public rooms and a 12.5 feet cathedral ceiling in the living room. The primary bedroom has sliders opening to the screened patio, wood floors, a large walk-in closet and en-suite bath with walk-in shower and bidet. The desired EXTENDED CATALINA split-plan layout allows plenty of privacy. The two additional bedrooms are perfect for your family or guests. Beautiful landscaping enhances this home as does the extended 2-car garage. Accordian Shutters allow the oversized patio to be enclosed from the elements. The Inlets is conveniently located between Sarasota and Venice. This stand-alone condo includes cable TV, internet, lawn maintenance, exterior insurance, and community amenities in the monthly fee. There is a large-heated pool with spa, exercise room, tennis courts, pickleball, a clubhouse and a wide range of social activities. Walk, bike, or just relax and enjoy this beautifully landscaped waterfront community. Two small pets (under 40 pounds) are allowed. This gorgeous unit is located just a mile to Nokomis Beach. Welcome home to the Inlets. Flood Zone downgraded from AE to X500. NOTE: Photos are PRIOR to roof and pool cage replacement.

NOKOMIS

105 INLETS BOULEVARD 105

3 Beds

2 Baths

2,683 Sq.Ft.

$869,000

MLS#: A4654828

Welcome to Bellacina by Casey Key, an exclusive gated community in Nokomis, offering the best of coastal elegance and convenience. This meticulously designed 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom pool home features a den and a spacious tandem 3-car garage. Lush landscaping creates a captivating first impression, leading into an interior where luxury abounds with soaring 10-foot ceilings, 8-foot doors, and soft-close cabinetry throughout. The gourmet kitchen is a chef’s dream, boasting 42-inch cabinetry, top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances including a gas range, a prep sink in the island, and a walk-in pantry, making it perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. The open-concept design ensures seamless flow between living spaces, enhanced by two sliding glass doors that open from the family room and kitchen to the expanded screen-enclosed lanai. Designed for year-round enjoyment, the lanai offers a large covered area, perfect for dining, lounging, or entertaining, rain or shine. The heated pool and spa provide a private retreat, surrounded by lush landscaping that enhances both privacy and ambiance. Whether you’re enjoying a morning coffee in the shade, hosting a sunset gathering, or unwinding in the spa after a long day, this outdoor oasis is a highlight of the home. The primary suite serves as a true retreat, featuring an en-suite bath with a spacious tiled shower, dual sinks, and a private water closet for added privacy. One guest bedroom includes its own en-suite bathroom, creating a private guest suite ideal for family or visitors, while the other offers a pocket door to transform it into a second suite. The versatile den, adorned with French glass doors, is perfect for a home office or library, offering flexibility to suit your lifestyle. Bellacina by Casey Key is a maintenance-free, resort-style community offering luxury amenities and an active lifestyle. Residents enjoy a clubhouse, heated lagoon pool and spa, fitness center, fire pit, tennis and bocce courts, dog park, and scenic walking trails. An on-site activities director keeps the social calendar full of events. Located just minutes from Casey Key and Nokomis Beach, this gated community provides easy access to pristine Gulf waters, world-class golf courses, the Legacy Trail for biking and walking, and nearby waterfront dining and entertainment. Experience the best of coastal Florida living in this sought-after neighborhood!

NOKOMIS

5673 PICCOLO STREET

3 Beds

3 Baths

3,504 Sq.Ft.

$850,000

MLS#: A4646548

Available now, new construction! Welcome to this beautifully upgraded Stellar floor plan, offering 3 spacious bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, a versatile den, and a 3-car garage. This home is designed with comfort, elegance, and functionality in mind. The heart of the home is the gourmet kitchen, featuring quartz countertops, an oversized pantry, and an open layout that flows seamlessly into the large gathering area – perfect for entertaining guests. High ceilings and a tray ceiling in the gathering room add an extra touch of sophistication. The owner’s suite is truly a retreat, complete with a tray ceiling, a massive walk-in closet, and an oversized en suite bath with an extended walk-in shower. One of the secondary bedrooms also features a private en suite, ideal for guests or multi-generational living. Additional upgrades include zero corner sliders that blur the line between indoor and outdoor living, and a fully updated laundry room with cabinets, a sink, and countertops. Nestled in the esteemed Palmer Ranch area, Talon Preserve is a gated community offering a resort lifestyle with open floor plans, gourmet kitchens, and large outdoor living spaces. For those looking for resort lifestyle communities with private amenities and modern houses, or luxury homes for sale in Nokomis, FL, Talon Preserve should be your top choice. Neighborhood features include 18,000 sq. ft. Grand clubhouse with large community room for events, catering kitchen, social lounge, outdoor lounge, card-craft room and classic arcade room, State-of-the-art fitness center, performance training room and group fitness studio, 8 Pickleball courts, 2 Tennis courts, 4 Bocce courts, playground, firepit lounge, dog park, resort style pool, heated spa, splash pad, full-service restaurant bar & grill, & more!

NOKOMIS

5958 TALON PRESERVE DRIVE

3 Beds

3 Baths

3,512 Sq.Ft.

$850,000

MLS#: TB8374374

HUGE PRICE REDUCTION...PRICED TO SELL...MOTIVATED SELLER! Step into perfection and SELLER CONCESSIONS towards closing costs/mortgage points, makes this the perfect opportunity! Offering the ideal blend of luxury, comfort, and modern convenience in this 4 bedroom 2.5 bath home situated in the highly desirable golf community of Calusa Lakes. This meticulously renovated home boasts high-end finishes throughout, including beautiful, new limestone tile flooring with some areas featuring heated flooring for added comfort. There is a NEW ROOF in 2019, NEW AC in 2024, crown molding, freshly painted interior and attention to detail around every corner. You will be captivated by the one of a kind gourmet kitchen, which is truly a chef’s dream. Featuring sleek quartzite countertops with a stunning waterfall edge and matching flowing backsplash. The kitchen includes all high end Bosch appliances, built-in refrigerator, pot filler above the induction cooktop, extended storage space, and dual controlled wine refrigerator. Under-cabinet lighting adds a warm glow and designed with extra storage under the kitchen bar for added functionality. The family room features a modern electric fireplace, ideal for those cozy evenings. Perfectly designed throughout with impressive 8 feet, solid wood interior doorways, creating an open, airy feeling. Beautiful engineered light oak wood flooring in all the bedrooms, spacious custom designed closets, LED lights with remote control and motorized drapes and surround sound allow for easy customization of ambiance. Spa-like bathrooms some of which include marble tiles, quartz counter tops, floating cabinet, and the electric towel drying system adds a touch of luxury and convenience. Step outside to the limestone lanai, features a recently refinished, stunning salt water pool with hot tub, propane heat pump, with new WIFI controller coupled with an outdoor shower ensuring year-round enjoyment. The home is also equipped with a generator, water filtration system and security system with camera for peace of mind. For added comfort the garage is air-conditioned and has epoxy flooring, garage doors includes a chainless opener with a long-lasting battery. Everything you could dream of in your Florida home! Be sure to view the AERIAL & 3-D TOURS.

NOKOMIS

2112 CALUSA LAKES BOULEVARD

4 Beds

2 Baths

3,499 Sq.Ft.

$850,000

MLS#: A4632855

Experience luxury living in this exquisite home nestled within the gated community of Bellacina by Casey Key. Boasting private preserve views from your spacious lanai that can be entered through the large opening created by unique telescoping sliding doors that lead to the lovely outdoor space complete with a gas fireplace, space to sit and relax, an outdoor kitchen and private pool. The residence also includes plantation shutters on windows offering a perfect blend of elegance and privacy while all floors have wood-look tile. The desirable and rarely available Santini floor plan is thoughtfully laid out to provide large open spaces for living and entertaining guests. Notable upgrades in this plan include a coffee bar adjacent to the kitchen and “drop zone” as you enter the home from the garage. The gourmet kitchen has abundant cabinetry, a large walk-in pantry and an expansive preparation island ideal for gracious entertaining. The primary bedroom is spacious with a spa-like bath with designer features and a custom closet that has direct access to the laundry room and, there is hurricane protection on all openings. Bellacina by Casey Key offers gated resort-style living with its spacious pool and spa, state-of-the-art fitness center within the community clubhouse that also features meeting spaces, a billards room and social gathering choices. Just beyond the clubhouse are tennis, pickle ball and bocce ball courts and direct access to the scenic Legacy trail. This exquisite home is in an ideal location that offers privacy yet is convenient to beaches, shopping, restaurants and more.

NOKOMIS

5601 PICCOLO STREET

3 Beds

2 Baths

3,290 Sq.Ft.

$850,000

MLS#: A4658321

This private pool home checks every box with stylish upgrades, the ultra popular "Lazio" floor plan, and a backyard built for relaxing or entertaining year-round! With 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and a versatile den, the home welcomes you with a bright foyer and crown molding that continues through the den and main living area. The den offers flexible space for a home office, playroom, or hobby room. The living room features a tray ceiling and sliding doors that open to the lanai, while the open dining area flows seamlessly into both the living space and kitchen. The kitchen offers an oversized island with quartz counters, stainless steel appliances, a pantry closet, and its own set of sliders leading out back. The primary suite is tucked into the back corner of the home and features a tray ceiling, space for a seating area or reading nook, an en suite bathroom with dual vanities, and an oversized walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms are located near the front—one with its own en suite bathroom, and the other just steps from a full guest bath. The exterior oasis offers an expansive covered lanai providing room for both lounging, sunbathing, entertaining, and dining, while the screened enclosure surrounds a sparkling in-ground pool with a waterfall feature—a true private retreat. Your storage and hobby space needs are well handled with the 3 car tandem garage. Bellacina by Casey Key is a gated, maintenance-free community offering resort-style amenities including a heated pool with cabanas, clubhouse, fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, bocce, dog parks, walking trails, and a full-time Activities Director. All just a quick golf cart ride to Nokomis Beach and a short drive to Venice, Siesta Key, and downtown Sarasota. Purchase with confidence, the seller is including a 1 year homebuyer warranty policy for your peace of mind!

NOKOMIS

5596 CANTUCCI STREET

3 Beds

3 Baths

3,459 Sq.Ft.

$850,000

MLS#: A4657792

Truly Unique Waterfront property with your own Private Beach area with direct access to the Gulf America (Mexico) a Boaters Paradise. The property is a rare find offering 5 bedrooms and 3 baths in highly sought after Nokomis Florida. Outside features of the home include a large deep pool with diving board, Workshop, both front and rear screened-in patio's, Playground area, sand beach relaxation along with boat dock and lift, making it a Great place for your own backyard Vacations. Other quality updated to this special property include Hurricane impact windows, Metal roof, extended 54x30 paved lanai partially, New septic field 2020, New Paver Driveway 2023, $40,000 in Solar panels (fully paid for) resulting in an average $75 monthly electric bills. This well-built home NEVER Flooded during the hurricanes of 2024. Beautiful water and Sunset views from the Kitchen, Dining, and Family rooms. Enjoy the convenience of being close to A+ Rated schools, shopping, dining and easy access to the New Sarasota Memorial Hospital and I-75, while having a private retreat to call Home. One Year Home Buyers Warranty thru American Home Shield. WELCOME HOME....

NOKOMIS

619 ALBEE FARM ROAD N

3 Beds

3 Baths

3,243 Sq.Ft.

$849,000

MLS#: A4655005

#N6137128

NOKOMIS

1596 LANDFALL DRIVE

3 Beds

2 Baths

3,597 Sq.Ft.

$849,000

MLS#: N6137128

1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 ... 36

Buyers resources

7 Reasons to Work with a Realtor

7 Principles For Home Buying Success

Getting a Mortgage To Buy a Home

Home Hazards Awareness

Key Items For Home Inspection

Questions When Buying a Condo

Questions When Choosing a Realtor

Sellers resources

8 reasons to work with a realtor

Calculating Capital Gains

Checklist for Better Showing

Cleaning Home For Sale

Improving Odds Of an Offer

Preparing Home for photoshoot

Selling Your Home for More $$

Buyers resources

BUYERS RESOURCES

Sellers resources

SELLERS RESOURCES

properties found. properties found. Page of .

- property

Send a message

Message successfully sent.

First Name

Last Name

Email

Phone

MLS Property Number

Your message

Reason for contacting?

Buying a home

Selling a home

Other

I agree to receive email communication and understand I can unsubscribe at any time.

Virtual Assistant

Would you like to receive some additional information on this specific property or similar properties?

Yes, I would like more information.

Thank You for Your Reply, One of Our Agents will contact you as soon as possible

No, maybe later.

Thank you, you can always contact me via email, phone number or through the contact form.

Realhub AI

Lucy - Your AI-Powered Realtor

Update Your Temporary Password

Accessibility Menu

Personalize your search

Enter your email and we'll notify you immediately when new listings match what you're looking for.

or enter email address

Email address (Must be valid)

Already have an account ? Login here

Continue your home search

Email address

First name First Name

Last name Last Name

Phone number (Optional)

Password

I agree to receive communications and understand I can unsubscribe at any time.

Already have an account ? Login here